I've tried a couple and this one has absolutely worked the best!

I have tried it for two days. The noise feature my dog believes it rewarding and the vibrate does nothing. He is very confused but so can’t wait to work with him and get him ready for off leash trips to the lake and beach!

Good value and great functions

This is a great collar! Comfortable fabric collar, the remote is nice and small.

I have a very fast and active mini Australian Shepherd who enjoys getting into mischief. With my voice commands and beep reinforcement, my dog always obeys now!! I’m amazed at the battery life too (only have to charge every 3-4 weeks). Look no further...you’ll be completely satisfied with this training collar!!

Works very well. The beep sound is louder than other collars I have tried. I mostly use this function. The shock is strong, I’ve only needed to use this once on the lowest setting. Seems to be well made. I always test it on myself before trying it on my pup, definitely start on the lowest setting!